When I observe what is happening to America—the country where I grew up, in which I was educated, and where I served in the U.S. Army—I am appalled. Crime, violence, looting. This is NOT the country I know and love. This is an aberration, a disfigurement of our Republic.
America’s past is a checkered one. No doubt about it. Slavery, discrimination, lynching. They are stains on our history, blemishes on an imperfect nation. Yet, America remains the only country where people can strive freely for a more perfect union, where they are free to speak their minds, to protest, to worship as they wish, to be individuals, to pursue happiness, and to hold elected officials accountable without fear of retribution.
Today, some want to rip our nation apart and divide us into belligerent tribes based on race, religion, ethnicity, wealth, poverty, achievement, failure, livelihood, and political power. As a firm believer in America’s motto: E Pluribus Unum (Out of Many, One), I will oppose the tribalists to my last breath.
Yesterday, millions of Americans voted in the critical midterm elections, and many of those did so wondering if their ballots would be counted honestly and if election officials would behave with integrity by making sure only American citizens voted and not the millions of people who have entered our nation illegally during the Biden administration or who reside in cemeteries.
A while back, I posted a commentary by fellow author Patrick J. Walsh. In it, Walsh shares some observations that are as true today as when his commentary originally appeared. Here it is again. I hope you will find them as illuminating and significant as I have.
The Dangers of Voting by Mail
Concerns about corruption in voting are not a new phenomenon. During the Constitutional Convention of 1787, James Madison worried about the abuses that might occur under the new Constitution.
Our federal system of government is predicated on the faith that a citizen, adequately informed and unmolested, is capable of judging who is best fit to govern our country.
The U.S. Constitution stipulates – “the times, places and manner of holding elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by law make or alter such regulations.”
Over time, what has developed in the United States is a system of voting protecting both the legitimacy of an election and the privacy rights of the voter from outside interference. Without these two components, we would have no fair, stable system of elections. All would descend to the chaos of corruption.
Two years ago, Democrats used the coronavirus as an excuse to abolish how we conduct elections in the United States.
Our current voting system came into being due to a great progressive reform movement in the latter part of the 19th century and early 20th century.
Ardent progressive reformers, like the socialist Henry George in 1886, strove to prevent corruption in the electoral process. The progressive reformers championed a system of voting by an official ballot printed at public expense by a neutral authority. Previously political parties had printed their own ballots, and ward bosses paid people to vote for their candidates, stuff ballots, and vote repeatedly.
The system was intimidating and enormously corrupt. A supervisory public authority was necessary to monitor balloting, ensure fairness, and provide the necessary element of voter secrecy.
The new reform structure, called the ‘Australian ballot’ (named after its place of origin), specifies that a citizen coming to the poll be registered to vote and identified. At the poll, he gives his name and address. He receives an official ballot, marks it in the secrecy of a booth, and hands it in to be counted.
Additional laws were passed protecting the voter from solicitation at the polls. These laws still survive today. Wardens at voting places acting on laws regulated by the local secretary of state keep those soliciting votes 100 ft. away from voters when they enter a polling place.
Massachusetts was the first state to adopt the secret ballot in 1888. By 1896, almost 90 percent of states had adopted it. The secret ballot is largely credited with rooting out the worst forms of voter fraud and intimidation. Later, voting machines came into being, which eliminated the paper ballot but ensured the same secrecy protections were kept with a curtain on the voting machine.
The corruption of the old political machine politics boss has ended, but the Democratic party today seeks to bring back Tammany Hall by a procedure called “Vote by Mail,” which takes away voter privacy and mails millions of ballots often to those no longer living at the address the ballot is mailed to.
One should not confuse “Vote by Mail” with voting by an ‘absentee ballot.’ Absentee balloting is an older, established, regulated process. It is used in extraordinary circumstances for illness or absence when the voter cannot appear at the poll. Ballots are requested by the voter, are registered, and require a signature certification by the voter.
There has been corruption in absentee balloting. The most secure voting method is to vote in person at the poll.
“Vote by Mail’ which the Democrats are advocating nationally, is an irresponsible, unregulated system that seeks to mail ballots to every address in the country from inaccurate unpurged voter rolls regardless of whether the persons at the address is living, currently registered to vote, or are even citizens. Critics point out that ballots delivered to the wrong address or to someone who moved would be piled up in hallways for anyone to pick up and tamper with.
‘Vote by Mail” then allows the ballots mailed to be collected by unregulated political activists who are entrusted to bring them to election places to be counted. What happens along the way to these ballots is left to the horror of one’s imagination. There are no voter identity checks anywhere in the ‘Vote by Mail” scheme. Its insecure procedures encourage tampering and ballot fraud on a massive scale.
In the 2018 midterm elections, Republicans in the state of California were winning on election night in seven Congressional districts, but the vote-harvested ballots allowed by “Vote by Mail” overturned the election results, giving all seven seats to the Democrats.
Some sections of California were found to have a voter registration of 112% — more registered voters than there were actual citizens! This is corruption, pure and simple.
Fair elections are an essential part of the integrity of a republic. Any process that does not guarantee voter protection is an attack on the U.S. Constitution and on every voter’s civil rights.
‘Vote by Mail” denigrates U.S. citizenship and the integrity of the electoral process as it takes away the dignity and responsibility of a citizen appearing at a polling place while invading the voter’s privacy as the ballot passes through so many different hands. The voting booth is the last citadel of privacy in America.
The progressive reforms of the early 20th century are a proud part of American history. Various states in our federal republic became laboratories of democratic electoral reform. It would be a disaster to the integrity of the electoral process to turn the clock back to the days of ballot stuffing, bribery, and Boss Tweed.
Patrick J. Walsh is an author based in Quincy, Mass.